It is not with glee or jubilation that we report that Deshann Brown has been found guilty of animal cruelty in the death of Mercy the Dog.
It is with a sadness for all of society that there would be someone among us humans who could be guilty of pouring flammable liquid on a dog as she lay on her back, then setting her on fire.
We feel the same sadness when we read of maimed and murdered people -- adults and babies. We know that humans are largely a nice bunch, but, good grief, ever so often something takes over and people fail to be good and decent.
So, in honor of the good and decent people on the planet, we'll move along now with attempt to help others and, later, we'll return to the Mercy trial.
MISSING DOG: If you'll scroll down to an "alert" posted last night, you'll see that Bodey, the blind German Shorthaired Pointer/Lab mix we've been trying to help find a home, has vanished. Details are on the earlier post.
FOUND DOG: Brenda Arnold found this female dog on Monday in the White Rock Lake area. "She was freshly bathed and wearing a new purple collar. She knows commands and is better trained than my dogs," Brenda says.
Now, the problem is the dog has no place to go. She's staying in Brenda's front yard -- she's loose, but has been staying in the yard. Brenda's home is under construction and there's no place to secure the dog.
"She came at a bad time and no one else seems to want to help," Brenda writes. "Do you know where is the best place to take her?"
Brenda says she "thinks she was dumped, even with the new collar and bath. I've been to many vets, pet shops and other dog places and no one recognizes her."
If you can help Brenda with this dog situation, e-mail her at [email protected] or call 214-232-0082.
Brenda is discouraged. "I have e-mailed 100s of people." No response.
The dog may have arrived at a bad time, but, surely, there's a good heart out there somewhere.
BELLA NEEDS A HOME TODAY: "I don't know what to do for this poor baby," writes Dorrie Mowery. "She is only six months old. I just hate to not even give her a chance..."
Bella is a 6-month-old dog who wandered up into Dorrie's backyard with her brother. The brother has been adopted. But Bella has no prospects right now. She's living in the backyard because she can't live with Dorrie's cat indoors.
When found, Bella was underweight, covered with fleas and starving. She has since been nursed back to health, spayed, vaccinated and is on flea and heartworm preventative.
Dorrie says Friday is the last day she can keep Bella and then it's going to be a ride to the pound or whatever shelter will take the dog. To offer to help Bella call 214-232-0082 or e-mail [email protected].
WHAT ABOUT TWO BASENJIS? Well, we have two to discuss. Dorothy and Bill Bruster found them on the loose in Wills Point in East Texas.
Efforts are underway to get the pair hooked up with the Dallas Basenji rescue group or to find their original home.
The dogs were found on Sept. 16. "We are beginning to think thee guys may have been stolen from somewhere else and 'dropped off' here," Dorothy says.
If anyone wants to help or to discuss this pair of Basenjis, contact the Brusters at [email protected] or call 903-873-6140 or 972--979-3929.
PRAISE FOR READERS: We mentioned a couple of days ago that we knew some folks who have a little money they want to give to a needy cat rescue group. The person who has been handling those "nominations," says, "I can't tell you how wonderful your readers are!! But you probably already knew that. Now the only problem is whom to choose."
The size of the pending donation is modest, and our tipster says, "We tell ourselves that anything is better than nothing, but I feel so bad now that all these rescues have come to light and they all are so needy."
Yes, nobody gets rich in critter rescue. They are, however, enriched by what they do.
IRVING GETS A BIG CAT: Yesterday we mentioned all the big cats in the Irving Animal Shelter and as that report was appearing, this cat Ghost was being turned in as an "owner release."
Our Irving cat tipster Rhonda Barrientos says that 5-year-old Ghost weighs in at "a whopping 34 pounds."
He's going to be checked out for health problems, of course.
"He is so overweight that he basically just lies there on a towel," says Rhonda. "The whole time I was there, I only saw him get up once and that was to use the litterbox. He returned to his towel after that.
"He probably hasn't been able to see de to his grooming needs in a long time, and he has very dry, probably itchy skin."
He loved being groomed with a wire brush she says. "He was once a beautiful cat, you can tell, and he could be again -- with a healthy diet and lots of TLC. He has incredible sky blue eyes."
You can ask about Ghost at the Irving Animal Shelter, 100 N. Briery Road, just east of the Belt Line intersection with Rock Island, south of 183. Call 972-721-2256.
THE MERCY TRIAL: The important thing to remember about this Mercy the Dog trial, the one where a guy was found guilty in her death, is that it means something. It means that a stronger animal cruelty law is in place. It means Dallas County isn't going to say, "It's just an animal" and move on.
The last day of the guilt/innocence phase of the trial packed the courtroom. Animal people, the defendant's kin, reporters and lawyers and other courtroom personnel came in to watch as the prosecution team (Terri Moore and David Alex) and the defense team (Dan Wyde and Lee Westmoreland) offered their closing arguments.
There wasn't an empty seat until, in the middle of Defense Attorney Wyde's argument, a pro-animal person got up and walked out muttering. I know she was muttering because I was out in the hall, having arrived too late to get inside the courtroom.
The TV folks were filming the proceedings through a courtroom window and catching the audio on a mike inside the court -- all OK'd by the judge. So at any time during the closing, you could see a dozen or so people gathered around the monitor in the hall and listening to the arguments.
It is interesting that this case brought so many people to the courthouse -- one wonders if justice would get more respect in the world if all cases were to draw a healthy gallery to the courtroom. People should dress nicely for the courthouse, too -- some defendants dress as if they're going to a ditch-digging. Show some respect.
Justice really should matter to us all whether it's a case of two old friend stabbing each other over a beer or someone killing another human being over money. Justice matters. It is part of the muscle that keeps democracy operating.
Now, in their closing arguments, the prosecution simply followed up on the testimony, pointing out to the jury that given the time and apartment logistics on April 13, 2006, given the witness testimony of who they saw where carrying a gasoline can, and who they saw with the dog, that there was only one conclusion. The defendant was the guilty party.
The defense rightly argued that nobody had actually SEEN the defendant douse the dog with gasoline and set it ablaze. And the defense attacked the credibility of some of the state's witnesses. And, indeed, one of the witnesses was such a juvenile thug that his record could only be discussed behind closed doors.
Face the fact: This was not a trial composed of characters from Mayberry.
In fact, one of the few innocent beings in the entire proceeding was Mercy the dog, apparently killed because she refused to mate with another dog.
The juvenile thug, forced to be lucid on the stand, got over his suddenly bad memory and testified that Mr. Brown stabbed the dog in frustration.
Testimony showed that the flammable liquid had been poured on the dog's underside as she lay on her back. Other testimony showed she was a docile dog. And it is likely that, as she was led behind a trash bin hours after being stabbed, she had become afraid of her hulking owner and had rolled on her back in a submissive position. She was then doused and lit and ran flaming across the apartment property.
The defense suggested that someone else may have been involved in this assault, but produced no one.
It appears that the jury must have followed the path of circumstantial evidence that placed the defendant and the dog and the gasoline all in the same place at the same time. And since neither Lee Harvey Oswald nor O.J. nor O.J.'s "Real Killers" were on the suspect list, the spotlight shone brightly on the defendant.
After the attorneys finished their closing arguments, the jury was sent to the jury room to deliberate.
I'm told that there are two bathrooms in the jury room. Speculation is the jurors went into the jury room, took turns in the facility, elected a foreman, read the charge and took one vote.
They'd left the courtroom about 4:10 p.m. and the judge read their verdict at 5 p.m. That's a quick verdict. I covered courts for many years and can't recall a quicker verdict. I'm sure there have been quicker jury votes. But, this one was so fast it caught several TV crews by surprise.
When the verdict was read, the formerly overflowing courtroom was only about half full of a few lawyers, some reporters, animal folks and a couple of the defendant's supporters. His mom, who had been patiently waiting in the hall, did not come into the courtroom.
Your heart has to go out to her -- nobody expects your kid to grow up and make headlines in such a disgusting fashion.
(That photo is of Mercy's final resting place in Operation Kindness' Memorial Garden.)
Oh, the thing is God bless dogs, they're so forgiving. But Mercy's tail no longer wags to signal a happy hello. Her eyes no longer look up lovingly at people who treat her with respect. She is now a memory, her photographs mere props in a courtroom drama in a state that once treated animal cruelty with a "so what" attitude.
If Mercy were alive and someone had led her into that courtroom Thursday afternoon, she'd probably have wagged her tail and gone happily to the only person she recognized.
Isn't that a sad irony.